Pie Apples 

I am in search of good pie apples! I have made many apple recipes over the years for everything imaginable. All have been very good. The only problem I have is with my pies. I have made many apple pie recipes. Although very good, I have not been happy with the apples. Most have cooked up way too much for me. I do not like “mushy” apples in anything, especially my pies. The Bob Evans Restaurant has been having apple pie (actually called apple dumpling pie) in the fall of the year over the last few years. It is delicious! It has large halves of apples along with small diced apples. I must tell you, it is among the best that I have ever eaten. Someone told me they are made with Macintosh apples.

pie applesApple Pie with Fuji Pie Apples
Apple Pie with Rome Beauty ApplesApple Pie with Rome Beauty Apples

I am sure you have heard the saying “As American as apple pie”. The first colonists brought apple seeds with them from Europe to New England. From there, apples spread across the land to the west coast. Many question whether our first colonies could have survived and move on westward without these apples. They were eaten fresh and dried for the harsh winter months. From these dried apples, they were stewed, baked, fried in many dishes and served as pie apples. Dried apples were easy to pack for the journey westward. They were even used medicinally.

As an Ohioan, we learned at an early age the story of Johnny Apple Seed. Johnny Apple Seed is credited with spreading seeds randomly everywhere he went. He didn’t plant a tree but nurseries in many states including much of Ohio. From these first apples, many varieties have been developed. Quite a few are considered excellent for pie apples; Braeburn, Cortland, Gala, Grevenstein, Golden Grimes, Jonathan, Rome Beauty, Transparent, Winesap and the most popular being the Granny Smith. My problem is that I have tried some of these and was terribly disappointed; most cooked too “mushy”.

I wanted to try the Macintosh for pie apples as I was told the Bob Evans Restaurant uses and they are rated good as apples, but they were not available. I decided I would try two others and see which did the best job. I already had (Fuji) Fugi apples so I thought I would try them; they are my favorite when it comes to eating them raw. I bought some Rome Beauty from the local produce stand to also try since they were rated excellent as pie apples.

I used basically the same recipe; one exception was the flour. The Rome Beauty, a baking apple, I used 3 tablespoons flour in the apples. The Fugi being a very crisp juicy apple, I used ½ cup of flour in the apples to thicken the juice more. I used ten apples in each; half I sliced thinly and half I cut in halves or quarters. After tossing in sugar, flour, cinnamon and nutmeg, I arranged the slices on the bottom and the larger pieces on the top. I baked them at the same temperature, both on the bottom shelf of my oven and both for the same amount of time. Both came out very tasty pies, but different.

Even though I added a lot more flour to the recipe, the Fugi apple pie had a lot more juice. Even though I coated the bottom crust with corn syrup, this juice made the bottom crust more soggy. It was flavorful but not as good as the Rome Beauty apple pie. Also the Fugi apples were much tougher than the Rome Beauty apples. Now, for the Rome Beauty pie apples; if I had not made it with larger pieces of apples on the top of the slices and used all sliced apples instead, it would have cooked up too much for my taste. The apples did cook up but the large pieces kept the pie nice and full.


  • Pie dough
  • 10 Apples (Peeled, cored, sliced and cut)
  • 2/3 Cup white sugar
  • ¼ Cup packed brown sugar
  • 3 Tablespoons flour (Juicy apples need more)
  • 1 Teaspoon cinnamon
  • ½ Teaspoon nutmeg
  • Pinch salt
  • 1 Tablespoon butter
  • 2 Tablespoons corn syrup
  • 1 Lightly beaten egg white

Preheat oven to 400F degrees; line bottom shelf of oven with aluminum foil to catch juice drippings.

Grease deep dish pie plate or pan; roll pie dough and press in pan.

Brush bottom of dough with corn syrup to help prevent soggy crust from juice.

Combine sliced apples and larger pieces of apples in a large bowl; add sugars, flour, cinnamon, salt and nutmeg.

Stir apples mixture to coat well with all ingredients; place sliced apples in bottom of crust and then place larger pieces over the top.

Roll top crust out and place over the apples; make slits or holes somehow to let the steam escape.

Cut excess pie dough away and crimp pie crust edges together to seal; brush with lightly beaten egg white and sprinkle with a little sugar.

Bake pie for 1 hour; cool before cutting.

Fuji Apple Pie Before BakingFuji Apple Pie Before Baking
Rome Beauty Apple Pie Before BakingRome Beauty Apple Pie Before Baking
Fuji Apple PieFuji Apple Pie
Fuji Apple PieFuji Apple Pie
Rome Apple PieRome Apple Pie
Rome Apple PieRome Apple Pie


Four Pie Apple PieFour Pie Apple Pie
Four Pie Apple Pie PieceFour Pie Apple Pie Piece

Multiple pie apples can be used in the same pie. I like to do this for a blend of flavors and textures. I used 4 types of apples in this recipe; Calville Blanc d’ Hiver, Twenty Ounce, Macintosh and Winesap. Each one of these cooked to a different degree in the order I listed them. This pie crust recipe is delicious and a little different having leavening in it. You do not need to worry about handling this dough too much. If it doesn’t hold together at first, roll it again.

Pie Crust

  • 2 Cups flour
  • ¾ Teaspoon salt
  • 1 ½ Teaspoons baking powder
  • 1 Tablespoon sugar
  • ¾ Cup PLUS 2 tablespoons solid shortening
  • ½ Tablespoon vinegar
  • 1 Egg
  • ¼ Cup cold water

Apple Filling

  • 8 Medium apples (4 Types of cooking apples)
  • 2 Tablespoons lemon juice
  • ¾ Cup sugar
  • 1 Tablespoon cinnamon

FOR CRUST sift together dry ingredients; cut in the shortening.

Beat egg in a small bowl; stir in the water and vinegar.

Mix egg mixture into dry ingredients; mix to a dough.

Turn out onto lightly floured surface; knead briefly until easy to handle.

NOTE: I make the dough first, wrap in plastic wrap and refrigerate until ready to roll.

FOR FILLING peel, core and slice apples; place in large bowl.

Sprinkle lemon juice over apples; toss to coat.

Sprinkle sugar and cinnamon over apples; toss again lightly.

PREHEAT OVEN TO 375F degrees; lightly grease bottom of deep dish pie plate.

TO ASSEMBLE roll out on floured surface half of the dough larger than pie plate.

Fit rolled dough into prepared pie plate; fill with prepared sliced apples.

Roll remaining dough out; fit over pie or cut strips for lattice.

Bake about 1 hour or until golden brown; cool on rack until warm.

Serve warm or cold; serves 8.